Insurance basics

How to Choose a Deductible for Car, Home and Health Insurance

Pick the highest deductible you could pay tomorrow, then check the break-even: extra out-of-pocket per claim divided by yearly savings. Car, home and health.

By Insurance Directory Listing Editorial Team11 min read

Every quote asks you to pick a deductible, and the choice moves two numbers in opposite directions. A higher deductible cuts your premium but raises what you pay when something goes wrong. The right number is the one you could actually pay, at a price gap worth taking.

Key takeaways

  • Raising a car deductible from $200 to $500 could cut collision and comprehensive costs by 15% to 30%, and going to $1,000 can save 40% or more, according to the Insurance Information Institute [1].
  • Car and home deductibles apply to each claim. Health deductibles usually apply once a year [2].
  • Many home policies carry a separate percentage deductible for wind, hail, hurricanes or earthquakes [2][4][5].
  • Break-even years = extra out-of-pocket per claim ÷ yearly premium savings. Run your quotes through our insurance deductible calculator.

Why does a higher deductible lower your premium?

A higher deductible lowers your premium because you agree to pay more of each claim yourself, so the insurer expects to pay out less. A deductible is “the amount of a claim that you must pay yourself,” as the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) puts it [3].

Take a $1,500 collision claim. With a $500 deductible, TDI’s example shows the insurer paying $1,000 [3]. With a $1,000 deductible, the same claim pays $500. Damage under $1,000 pays nothing at all, so many small claims are never filed. Less money paid out means less premium to collect.

How much you save depends on the coverage:

  • Car: Going from $200 to $500 could cut collision and comprehensive costs by 15% to 30%, the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) says, and $1,000 can save 40% or more [1].
  • Home and auto in general: TDI says moving from a $500 to a $1,000 deductible “can save as much as 20 percent” [2].
  • Health: HealthCare.gov notes that plans with lower monthly premiums generally have higher deductibles [7].

Those are ceilings, not promises. Only a quote at each deductible, from your insurer or a local insurance agent, tells you your real price.

How to choose a deductible in 6 steps

The same process works for car, home and health insurance. You need your current policy, a recent quote and your savings balance.

Step 1: Find the most you could pay tomorrow

Start with cash, not premiums. Triple-I’s advice: before choosing a higher deductible, “be sure you have enough money set aside to pay it if you have a claim” [1]. TDI says to think about how much you can afford to pay if your property is damaged [2].

Look at your emergency savings and pick the highest amount you could pay this week without a credit card or loan. That’s your ceiling. If it’s $500, a $2,500 deductible is off the table, however good the discount looks.

Step 2: Get quotes at two or three deductible levels

Ask your insurer or agent for the same policy priced at different deductibles, such as $500, $1,000 and $2,500. Keep every other limit identical so the deductible is the only change.

Write down the yearly premium for each. The gap between them is the only money a higher deductible earns you.

Step 3: Run the break-even math

Divide the extra out-of-pocket per claim by the yearly savings. The answer is how many claim-free years it takes for the savings to cover one claim’s extra cost.

Break-even years = (higher deductible − lower deductible) ÷ (old premium − new premium)

If you’d go longer than that without a claim, the higher deductible pays off. Our deductible calculator does this math and a 10-year cost comparison. A worked example follows below.

Step 4: Be honest about how often you claim

A deductible applies to every car or home claim [2]. Two claims in a year means paying it twice. Count the claims you’ve actually filed in the last 10 years, not the ones you hope to avoid.

Also think about which claims you’d file anyway. If you’d never file a $700 claim, a $500 deductible buys little protection.

Step 5: Check what your lender allows

If you have a mortgage or car loan, your lender has a say. Washington’s insurance regulator notes that a lien holder may set deductible requirements [5]. Fannie Mae, for example, caps the deductible on loans it buys at 5% of the property insurance coverage amount. Separate deductibles, such as windstorm or wildfire, can’t exceed 5% each [6]. Check your loan papers before you raise anything.

Step 6: Revisit it at every renewal

Your savings, your car’s value and your claim history change. Recheck the deductible each year using our policy renewal checklist. As your emergency fund grows, a higher deductible may become the smarter choice.

Worked example: is a $1,000 deductible worth it?

A $1,000 deductible on car insurance is good if you could pay $1,000 tomorrow and the yearly savings pay back the extra $500 in a few years. Here’s the math with illustrative quotes, not real prices.

Dana’s policy has a $500 collision and comprehensive deductible at $1,800 a year. Her insurer quotes $1,560 a year at $1,000. She has filed one claim in the last 10 years.

Step Calculation Result
Yearly savings $1,800 − $1,560 $240
Extra cost per claim $1,000 − $500 $500
Break-even $500 ÷ $240 About 2.1 years
10-year cost at $500 ($1,800 × 10) + ($500 × 1 claim) $18,500
10-year cost at $1,000 ($1,560 × 10) + ($1,000 × 1 claim) $16,600

At one claim per decade, the $1,000 deductible saves Dana $1,900. It stays cheaper until she’d file about five claims in 10 years: ($240 × 10) ÷ $500 = 4.8.

Now say the insurer had quoted only $60 a year in savings. Break-even would take more than eight years, and the lower deductible would be the better deal. Small price gaps favor low deductibles.

Pro tip: Enter your own quotes in the deductible calculator, including your real claim history. It shows the break-even years and the claim count at which the higher deductible stops paying off.

What is a good deductible for car insurance?

A good car insurance deductible is usually the highest amount, often $500 or $1,000, that you could pay from savings without strain. Use the break-even test above to pick between them.

Some car insurance rules shape the choice:

  • Which coverages have one. You pay a deductible on collision, comprehensive and uninsured/underinsured motorist claims, TDI says [3]. See comprehensive vs. collision for what each pays.
  • Not-at-fault claims. You don’t pay a deductible on a claim against the other driver’s insurance company [3]. If you file with your own insurer instead, you’ll pay it, and your insurer will probably try to collect from the other driver’s company [3].
  • Older cars. If your car is worth less than 10 times the premium, Triple-I says collision and comprehensive may not be cost effective at all [1].
  • Loans. Gap insurance may not pay your deductible after a total loss, as our gap insurance guide explains.

When do you pay the deductible for car insurance?

You pay the deductible when a claim is settled, not when you buy the policy. Usually the insurer subtracts it from the payment. In TDI’s example, a $1,500 collision claim with a $500 deductible means the insurer pays $1,000 [3]. You then pay the remaining $500 to the repair shop.

Compare quotes at two deductibles from local auto insurance agencies.

What is a good deductible for home insurance?

A good home insurance deductible is one you could pay twice in a year, since it applies to each claim [2]. But your policy may also have a second, larger deductible that matters more.

Percentage deductibles

Many home policies set a deductible as a percentage of the home’s insured value rather than a dollar figure. TDI’s example: on a home insured for $150,000, a 5% deductible is $7,500. A $6,500 roof repair would pay nothing [2]. Convert every percentage to dollars before comparing quotes.

Percentages commonly apply to:

  • Wind and hail. You may have separate deductibles for wind and hail damage and for other perils like fire and theft, TDI says [2].
  • Hurricanes. Nineteen states and Washington, D.C., have hurricane deductibles, typically 1% to 5% of the home’s insured value, according to Triple-I [4]. Our guide to hurricane damage coverage explains when they apply.
  • Earthquakes. Earthquake coverage usually has its own deductible of 10% to 20% of the coverage amount, Washington’s regulator says [5]. Local earthquake insurance agencies can quote options.

Here’s how that looks on a home insured for $350,000:

Deductible You pay first
$1,000 all-other-perils $1,000
1% wind/hail $3,500
2% wind/hail $7,000
5% hurricane $17,500

Make sure your savings can cover the percentage deductible, not just the $1,000 one. For what each part of the policy pays, see what homeowners insurance covers. Local home insurance agencies can quote both deductibles.

What is a good deductible for health insurance?

A good health insurance deductible depends on how much care you expect to use. Low users often save with a higher deductible and lower premium. Heavy users often save with a lower deductible, because they’ll reach it anyway.

Health deductibles work differently from car and home. The deductible usually covers a year, not each claim [2]. After you meet it, you usually pay only a copay or coinsurance [7]. Marketplace plans also cover certain preventive care in full before you meet the deductible [7]. For how those pieces fit together, see deductible vs. coinsurance vs. copay.

For context, the average deductible for workers with single coverage and a general annual deductible was $1,886 in 2025, according to KFF’s employer survey [12].

High-deductible plans and HSAs

A high-deductible health plan (HDHP) lets you save in a tax-advantaged Health Savings Account (HSA). The IRS sets the thresholds each year [9][10]:

Self-only / family 2026 2027
Minimum HDHP deductible $1,700 / $3,400 $1,750 / $3,500
Maximum out-of-pocket $8,500 / $17,000 $8,700 / $17,400
HSA contribution limit $4,400 / $8,750 $4,500 / $9,000

As of Jan. 1, 2026, bronze and catastrophic plans available through an Exchange count as HSA-compatible, the IRS says [11]. HealthCare.gov adds that if you don’t need much care, “you may benefit from the lower monthly premium” [8].

Compare total cost, not just the deductible

HealthCare.gov’s advice is to consider your total spending on health care, not just the premium [13]. Add a year of premiums to what you’d pay out of pocket in a quiet year and in a bad year. These plans are illustrative:

Plan A: high deductible Plan B: low deductible
Yearly premium $4,200 $6,240
Deductible $3,000 $1,000
Out-of-pocket maximum $8,500 $5,000
Quiet year ($500 of care) $4,700 $6,740
Bad year (out-of-pocket max reached) $12,700 $11,240

Plan A wins by $2,040 in a quiet year. Plan B wins by $1,460 in a bad one. If you expect surgery, a birth or regular specialist care, the lower deductible likely costs less. Browse local health insurance agencies to compare plans side by side.

Get quotes at two deductibles from a local agent

The fastest way to choose is to see real prices. Ask a local agent to quote your car or home policy at two or three deductibles, with every other limit the same. Then run the numbers through the break-even test.

Find insurance agents near you and ask each for the same two quotes.

Frequently asked questions

Is a $1,000 deductible good for car insurance?

A $1,000 car insurance deductible is good if you could pay $1,000 from savings tomorrow and the premium savings pay back the extra cost within a few claim-free years. Triple-I says going to $1,000 can save 40% or more on collision and comprehensive versus a $200 deductible [1]. If the quoted savings are small, stay lower.

Do you pay a deductible if you’re not at fault?

Not if you file with the at-fault driver’s insurance company. TDI says you don’t pay a deductible on claims against another driver’s insurer [3]. If you file with your own insurer for speed, you’ll pay your deductible, and your insurer will probably try to collect from the other company [3].

Is the deductible per claim or per year?

It depends on the insurance. Home and auto deductibles apply to each claim, while health deductibles usually cover a year, according to TDI [2].

Is a high-deductible health plan good?

A high-deductible health plan is good if you’re mostly healthy and want lower premiums, and it lets you save in an HSA. For 2026, the plan must have a deductible of at least $1,700 for self-only coverage [9]. If you expect heavy medical use, compare the total yearly cost of each plan first.

The bottom line

Pick the highest deductible you could pay tomorrow, then take it only if the yearly savings pay back the extra cost in a few claim-free years. Convert any percentage deductible to dollars first. For health plans, compare total yearly costs in a quiet year and a bad year.

Sources

  1. Insurance Information Institute, “Nine ways to lower your auto insurance costs” (undated)
  2. Texas Department of Insurance, “What to know about deductibles” (updated Oct. 14, 2024)
  3. Texas Department of Insurance, “Auto insurance guide” (updated Dec. 11, 2025)
  4. Insurance Information Institute, “Background on: Hurricane and windstorm deductibles” (undated)
  5. Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, “A consumer’s guide to: Homeowner insurance” (Rev. 3/26)
  6. Fannie Mae Selling Guide B7-3-02, “Property Insurance Requirements for One- to Four-Unit Properties” (topic dated Aug. 5, 2026)
  7. HealthCare.gov, Glossary: Deductible
  8. HealthCare.gov, “What are Health Savings Account-eligible plans?”
  9. IRS, Rev. Proc. 2025-19 (2026 HSA and HDHP amounts)
  10. IRS, Rev. Proc. 2026-24 (2027 HSA and HDHP amounts)
  11. IRS, “Treasury, IRS provide guidance on new tax benefits for health savings account participants under the One, Big, Beautiful Bill,” IR-2025-119 (Dec. 9, 2025)
  12. KFF, Employer Health Benefits 2025 Annual Survey, Summary of Findings
  13. HealthCare.gov, “Health plan categories: Bronze, Silver, Gold & Platinum”

Next step

Talk it through with a local agency

Take your questions to an agency near you. Run an agency? Claim your free listing.

Find an agency near you