When you turn an annuity into income, you pick who the payments cover and what happens to the money if you die early. That choice sets the size of every check, and once payments start you usually can’t change it [1][2].
Key takeaways
- A single life annuity pays the largest monthly amount because it covers one life and stops at death [3].
- Every added guarantee (a second life, a guaranteed period, a refund) lowers the monthly payment [3][4].
- In one PBGC illustration, a 100% joint and survivor option paid $409 a month against $500 for straight life [4].
- Pension plans must offer married workers a joint and survivor annuity, and the spouse must consent in writing to waive it [5][6].
What are annuity payout options?
Annuity payout options are the ways an insurer converts an annuity’s value into income: for one life, for two lives, for a fixed period, or a mix of these, with or without a refund guarantee. Regulators also call them settlement options [1].
The NAIC’s buyer’s guide describes the trade at the heart of every option. When you annuitize, you get guaranteed income payments “for life or a period of time you choose,” but after payments begin “you can’t take any other money out of the annuity” [2].
Annuity income is simply the stream of payments that comes out of this process. An income annuity is a contract bought mainly for that stream. It can be immediate, or a deferred income annuity that starts paying at a set future date. FINRA calls deferred income annuities “immediate annuities with a delayed payout phase” and notes the purchase is “generally an irrevocable decision” [7].
The options below apply to both kinds, and to deferred annuities you later annuitize. To find insurers and agents who sell them, browse our annuities insurance directory.
Annuity payout options at a glance
| Option | How long it pays | What heirs get | Monthly payment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single life (life only, straight life) | Your lifetime | Nothing | Highest |
| Life with period certain | Your lifetime, with a minimum period | Rest of the guaranteed period if you die early | Slightly lower |
| Life with cash or installment refund | Your lifetime | Unpaid premium, in cash or installments | Slightly lower |
| Joint and survivor | Until the second person dies | Survivor keeps 50% to 100% | Lower |
| Period certain only | A fixed term, such as 10 or 20 years | Rest of the term | Depends on term |
| Systematic withdrawal | Until you stop or the money runs out | Whatever is left | You choose |
The rows come from state regulator guides [1][3]. “Highest” and “lower” are relative: actual amounts depend on your age, your survivor’s age, interest rates and the insurer.
What is a single life annuity (straight life)?
A single life annuity pays you a set amount for as long as you live, and payments stop when you die. It’s also called a straight life, life only or “life income (no refund)” annuity [1][3].
Washington’s insurance regulator explains the pricing logic: “The longer you expect to live, the smaller your payments will be.” It also spells out the gamble. “If you don’t live long, you might not get all the money from your annuity,” but if you live a long time, “you might get more than your annuity is worth” [3].
Because the insurer owes nothing after your death, this option produces the biggest monthly check of any lifetime choice. That makes it a fit when:
- You’re single, or your spouse has enough income of their own.
- Your health and family history point to a long life.
- You want the most guaranteed income per dollar and have other assets for heirs.
The risk is concentrated in the first few years. If you die a year after annuitizing, the remaining value stays with the insurer under a pure single life contract.
What is a life annuity with period certain?
A life annuity with period certain pays for your whole life and also guarantees a minimum number of years, often 10, 15 or 20. If you die inside that window, your beneficiary receives the payments for the rest of the period [1][3].
A 10 year certain and life annuity is the common version. Under the federal Thrift Savings Plan rules, for example, if the participant dies “before annuity payments have been made for 10 years (120 payments),” payments continue to beneficiaries until 120 have been made [8].
If you outlive the period, nothing changes: you keep getting paid for life, and nothing passes to heirs at death. The guarantee costs you a little each month, which the example further down puts a number on.
What is a period certain annuity?
A period certain annuity pays for a set term you choose, such as 10, 15 or 20 years, and then stops, whether you’re alive or not. It’s not a lifetime income option [3].
Washington’s regulator gives an example: choose 15 years and die within the first 10, and “your beneficiary will get paid for the remaining 5 years” [3]. The flip side is that if you live past year 15, the income ends.
People use period certain payouts to bridge a gap, such as income until Social Security or a pension begins. They don’t protect against outliving your money.
What is a joint and survivor annuity?
A joint and survivor annuity pays while either of two people is alive, usually spouses. When the first dies, the survivor keeps receiving a set share of the payment for life [1][3].
Common survivor shares are 50%, two-thirds, 75% and 100% [1][4]. Under the TSP’s rules, a 50% survivor benefit pays the survivor half of what was paid while both were alive, and a 100% benefit pays the same amount [8].
Washington’s regulator notes these payments “are usually smaller than the life-only option, as your insurer will pay for whoever lives longer” [3]. The larger the survivor share, the smaller the starting check, as the PBGC example below shows [4].
Joint life annuity is a common label for the same idea: the TSP calls its versions a “joint life annuity with spouse” or “with another person” [8]. Labels vary by insurer, so confirm the survivor percentage in writing before you compare quotes.
Cash refund and installment refund annuities
A refund annuity pays for life and promises that, if you die early, your beneficiary gets back at least what you paid in, minus payments already made. It comes in two forms [1][8].
Cash refund. The beneficiary gets the difference in one lump sum. Under the TSP rules, if the annuitant dies before an amount “equal to the balance used” to buy the annuity has been paid out, the difference goes to the beneficiaries [8].
Installment refund. Payments continue to the beneficiary until the guaranteed amount is reached. Kentucky’s Annuity Buyer’s Guide describes the guarantee as a number of months: the annuity value divided by the first monthly payment [1].
Here’s how both work, using illustrative numbers, not an insurer quote. You buy a $100,000 life annuity that pays $600 a month:
- Installment refund: $100,000 ÷ $600 = 166.7, so roughly 167 payments are guaranteed. Die after 60, and your beneficiary receives about 107 more.
- Cash refund: Die after receiving $36,000 (60 × $600), and your beneficiary gets $100,000 − $36,000 = $64,000 at once.
Either way, once your payments pass $100,000, nothing more is owed to heirs.
Worked example: how each option changes the monthly check
The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) publishes an illustration for a pension plan. Sam starts benefits at 65, his wife Carol is 61, and straight life pays $500 a month [4]. Here’s what each option pays, with our arithmetic on the cut:
| Option (PBGC example) | Sam’s monthly benefit | Carol’s benefit after Sam dies | Cut vs. straight life |
|---|---|---|---|
| Straight life | $500 | $0 | None |
| 5-year certain and continuous | $494 | $494 for the rest of 5 years only | 1.2% |
| 10-year certain and continuous | $477 | $477 for the rest of 10 years only | 4.6% |
| 15-year certain and continuous | $452 | $452 for the rest of 15 years only | 9.6% |
| Joint and 50% survivor | $450 | $225 for life | 10.0% |
| Joint and 50% “pop-up” | $444 | $222 for life | 11.2% |
| Joint and 75% survivor | $429 | $322 for life | 14.2% |
| Joint and 100% survivor | $409 | $409 for life | 18.2% |
Cut = (500 − option) ÷ 500. In PBGC’s pop-up version, Sam’s benefit rises back to $500 if Carol dies first [4].
Two patterns stand out. Short guaranteed periods are cheap: the 5-year option costs Sam $6 a month. And protecting a spouse for life is where the price climbs: the 100% survivor option costs $91 a month, about $21,840 over 20 years of payments.
These are PBGC’s figures for one pension plan, not a commercial annuity quote. A private insurer’s percentages will differ, but the order of the options usually holds.
Should you annuitize, take a lump sum or withdraw?
Annuitizing isn’t the only way to take money from a deferred annuity. The NAIC buyer’s guide lists three paths [2]:
- Annuitize. Convert the value into one of the payout options above. Income is guaranteed, but you give up access to the lump sum.
- Full withdrawal. Take the cash surrender value in one payment and end the contract. You’ll likely pay a surrender charge during the surrender period, and you can’t start income payments from that contract afterward.
- Partial withdrawals. Take some money out and keep the contract. Most annuities with surrender charges let you take a set amount, usually up to 10%, each year without a charge.
A systematic withdrawal schedule turns partial withdrawals into a monthly payment you choose. Washington’s regulator warns that “your insurer won’t guarantee that payments will last the rest of your life” [3].
A guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit (GLWB) rider, usually sold at extra cost, bridges the two. You take withdrawals, the remaining money keeps earning, and if the account reaches zero the payments continue for life. If you die while receiving payments, survivors may get some or all of what’s left [2].
Pension plans: the qualified joint and survivor annuity rule
If your annuity comes from an employer pension, federal law picks the default for you when you’re married. In a defined benefit or money purchase plan, the form of payment includes a survivor’s benefit unless you and your spouse choose otherwise, according to the Department of Labor [5].
That default is the qualified joint and survivor annuity (QJSA). The survivor must receive at least half of the payment made during your joint lives. The DOL says 50% is typical, though some plans offer other levels such as 75% [5]. The IRS sets the range at no less than 50% and no more than 100% [6].
To choose single life instead, the rules are strict [5][6]:
- You both must receive a written explanation of the QJSA.
- You make a written waiver, within time limits set by the plan.
- Your spouse signs a written consent, witnessed by a notary or a plan representative.
Most 401(k) and other defined contribution plans follow different survivor rules, the DOL notes [5]. And a participant who waives the QJSA may be able to elect a qualified optional survivor annuity (QOSA) instead [6].
Some couples waive the survivor benefit and buy life insurance to protect the spouse, a strategy often called “pension max.” It only works if the policy stays in force, so compare term vs. whole life insurance and size the death benefit with our life insurance calculator before you sign away a survivor benefit.
Does the payout option change your taxes?
Not much, by itself. Taxes depend mainly on whether the annuity was bought with pre-tax or after-tax money. The IRS explains that if some of your contributions were already taxed, you can exclude part of each payment, and the total you exclude is generally limited to your cost [9].
Our guide to how annuities are taxed covers the exclusion ratio, withdrawals before age 59½ and inherited annuities.
What happens if the insurer fails?
A lifetime payout depends on the insurer staying solvent for decades. If an insurer fails, each state’s life and health insurance guaranty association protects policyholders up to limits set by state law [10].
For annuities, NOLHGA says the limits “apply to the present value of annuity benefits” [10]. Its state table, based on information as of June 1, 2025, shows [10]:
- $250,000 in most states, including Texas.
- $500,000 in New York and Utah.
- Florida: $250,000 for a deferred annuity and $300,000 once the annuity is in payout status.
- California: 80% of the annuity contract value, up to a $250,000 benefit limit.
FINRA cautions that guaranty funds may not cover a full loss [7]. If your income annuity would exceed your state’s limit, splitting the money between insurers is one way to stay under it.
How to choose an annuity payout option
Start with who depends on the income, then decide how much monthly payment you’ll give up for each guarantee.
- List who needs the money after you. A spouse with little other income points toward joint and survivor. No dependents points toward single life.
- Check your other income. Social Security, a spouse’s pension or savings can replace a survivor benefit you skip.
- Weigh health honestly. A single life annuity pays off for long lives. A short life expectancy favors a refund or period certain guarantee.
- Price each guarantee. Ask for quotes on every option side by side, as in the PBGC table, and compare the monthly cut with what the guarantee protects.
- Plan for inflation. FINRA notes deferred income annuity payments “are not adjusted for inflation” in general [7]. Some contracts offer rising payments, such as the TSP’s 2% annual increase option, at a lower starting amount [8].
- Cover end-of-life costs separately. A single life annuity leaves nothing at death, so a small final expense insurance policy can pay for the funeral.
Remember that the choice is usually permanent. Kentucky’s guide says that once payments start, “that option cannot be changed” [1].
Talk to a local agent before you annuitize
The best time to compare payout options is before you sign the annuitization form, while every option is still on the table. An agent can run quotes for each option and survivor percentage from several insurers.
Find insurance agents near you, or browse local agencies in our annuities directory. If you’re weighing life insurance alongside a pension decision, start with our life insurance directory.
Frequently asked questions
What is a straight life annuity?
A straight life annuity is another name for a single life annuity. It pays a fixed amount for the rest of your life and stops at your death, with no refund or guaranteed period for heirs [1][3]. Because the insurer’s obligation ends at death, it pays more per month than any other lifetime payout option.
Is a 10 year certain and life annuity worth it?
A 10 year certain and life annuity is worth it if leaving money to heirs after an early death matters to you and the monthly cut is small. In PBGC’s pension example, a 10-year guarantee lowered payments by 4.6%, from $500 to $477 [4]. Compare quotes for your own age before you decide.
Can you change your annuity payout option later?
Usually not. Kentucky’s Annuity Buyer’s Guide says that once a payout option is chosen and payments start, the option cannot be changed [1]. The TSP rules say the same: once purchased, the annuity type, features and joint annuitant can’t be changed [8]. Make the choice before you annuitize.
What is a deferred income annuity?
A deferred income annuity is a contract you buy now that starts guaranteed lifetime payments at a set future date. FINRA says the payments are generally larger than an immediate annuity’s for the same premium, but often for a shorter time, and buying one is generally irrevocable [7]. The payout options above still apply.
Is a fixed income annuity adjusted for inflation?
Usually not. A fixed income annuity pays a set amount, so its buying power falls as prices rise. FINRA says deferred income annuity payments generally aren’t adjusted for inflation, though an inflation rider is available at the cost of lower payments [7].
The bottom line
A single life annuity pays the most each month, and every guarantee you add for a spouse or heirs lowers that check. Price each option side by side before you annuitize, because the choice is usually permanent.
Sources
- Kentucky Department of Insurance, “The Annuity Buyer’s Guide” (July 2011). insurance.ky.gov
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners, “Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities” (revised 2013), reprinted by the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance. nj.gov
- Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, “Annuity payout options” (undated). insurance.wa.gov
- Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, “Benefit Options” (last updated Oct. 1, 2025). pbgc.gov
- U.S. Department of Labor, Employee Benefits Security Administration, “What You Should Know About Your Retirement Plan” (September 2021). dol.gov
- Internal Revenue Service, “Retirement topics: Qualified joint and survivor annuity” (last reviewed July 31, 2026). irs.gov
- FINRA, “Deferred Income Annuities: Plan Now for Payout Later” (July 15, 2022). finra.org
- 5 CFR § 1650.14, Annuities (Thrift Savings Plan), via Cornell LII. law.cornell.edu
- Internal Revenue Service, “Topic no. 411, Pensions: The general rule and the simplified method” (last reviewed Sept. 24, 2026). irs.gov
- National Organization of Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Associations (NOLHGA), “How You’re Protected” (information as of June 1, 2025). nolhga.com